Cookies, Cinnamon Rolls,

&

Baked Treats

Are you looking for a fancy sweet treat? Then you're in the right place.

We offer a variety of cookies, cinnamon rolls, muffins, and more.

Everything is made by hand—no pre-made dough, boxed cake mix, or icing in a plastic tub.

Dietary requests can be accommodated for non-dairy, tree-nut-free, plant-based, gluten-free, and/or sugar-free.

Fancy Cupcakes

Looking for a little sweet dessert, but don’t need a full dozen?

Look no further, Tasty Treats offers cupcakes for any occasion.

Fancy Cupcakes are available individually or in a pack of three (qty. 3).

Choose your cake flavor:

Chocolate, vanilla, marble, red velvet, strawberry, peanut butter, hazelnut, white chocolate, cheesecake, or pistachio.

Then choose your icing buttercream, chocolate ganache, or whipped cream.

Every fancy cupcake is topped with extra icing and sprinkles.

Order Cupcakes

Fancy Cookies

Our Fancy Cookies are extra-large, soft-baked cookies, perfect for any occasion. Each cookie measures 4” wide and 1.25” tall and pairs perfectly with an ice-cold glass of milk (or lactose-free milk).

Cookies are sold individually, in a half-dozen (qty. 6), and for the best bang for your dollar, we offer a discounted dozen (qty. 12).

We make custom sugar cookies on our Dessert Bar & Custom Treats page.

Here are a few of our best sellers:

Chocolate chunk, oatmeal chocolate chunk, brownie, brownie peanut butter chip, macadamia nut cranberry, simple sugar cookie with buttercream icing, and pumpkin spice!

Order Cookies

Fancy Muffins

Our fancy muffins are available in a variety of flavors, always made from scratch, with no added preservatives. Each order includes a side of whipped butter.

You can order Fancy Muffins individually, by the half dozen (qty.. 6) or for those looking for the best price, order a full dozen (qty. 12)

Here are a few of our favorites:

Blueberry, pumpkin spice, carrot raisin nut, banana nut, lemon blueberry, double chocolate, and sweet bran spice muffins.

Order Muffins